An Unofficial 'The Rest Is History' Reading List

14. Historical Fiction

January 11, 2021

Description

Is the author’s responsibility to the quality of the novel or the truth of history? What makes a great historical novel and which authors have contributed to our understanding of history. Tom...
Read more here

Books Referenced

Aubrey-Maturin series

Author: Patrick O'Brian

Context:

Discussed as naval historical fiction that Tom couldn't get through - gave up after 30 pages due to too much rope/nautical detail

Hornblower series

Author: C.S. Forester

Context:

Mentioned as naval fiction Emma Darwin grew up on, and Tom says he wasn't interested in either

In Search of Lost Time

Author: Marcel Proust

Context:

Referenced in a tweet comparing giving up on O'Brian to giving up on Proust after three pages because it's just about cake

The Eagle of the Ninth

Author: Rosemary Sutcliff

Context:

Mentioned as a classic way people come to Roman Britain through fiction, described as having enduring influence

The Sword at Sunset

Author: Rosemary Sutcliff

Context:

Described as a fabulous novel for adults about a historical Arthur in the 5th century after the Romans left

Asterix

Author: René Goscinny and Albert Uderzo

Context:

Tom mentions these comics/graphic novels as what got him particularly interested in the Romans

Wolf Hall trilogy

Author: Hilary Mantel

Context:

Discussed as the most successful/prestigious historical novels of the last ten years, with Thomas Cromwell as protagonist

A Man for All Seasons

Author: Robert Bolt

Context:

Mentioned as presenting opposite view to Hilary Mantel - Thomas More as hero rather than villain

A Game of Thrones series

Author: George R.R. Martin

Context:

Discussed as fantasy novels that take elements from Wars of the Roses but with unpredictable outcomes

The Accursed Kings series

Author: Maurice Druon

Context:

French series set in Hundred Years' War that partly inspired Game of Thrones

The White Company

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Context:

Mentioned as set in Hundred Years' War from English side, featuring Sir John Chandos and the Black Prince

Sir Nigel

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Context:

Mentioned alongside The White Company as Hundred Years' War fiction

An Instance of the Fingerpost

Author: Iain Pears

Context:

Nominated as the single best historical novel Tom has read - offers multiple perspectives on Restoration England

Shardlake series

Author: C.J. Sansom

Context:

Mentioned as very gripping novels, though criticized for having liberal humanist sceptic protagonist

The Last Kingdom series

Author: Bernard Cornwell

Context:

Set in Anglo-Saxon period, criticized for protagonist Uhtred being a 21st century liberal trapped in historical setting

The Leopard

Author: Giuseppe Tomasi di Lampedusa

Context:

Called a brilliant book about Italian unification, conservative in nature about anxiety of change

War and Peace

Author: Leo Tolstoy

Context:

Described as probably the most famous historical novel, noted for being about history itself and how history works

Crime and Punishment

Author: Fyodor Dostoevsky

Context:

Tom mentions being commissioned by The Economist to write about it, visiting St. Petersburg in Raskolnikov's footsteps

I, Claudius

Author: Robert Graves

Context:

Praised as the most successful attempt to ventriloquise someone from before the invention of the novel

Count Belisarius

Author: Robert Graves

Context:

Mentioned as incredibly boring because it reads like a Byzantine account of a campaign

Memoirs of Hadrian

Author: Marguerite Yourcenar

Context:

Mentioned as an attempt to mimic Hadrian's voice, described as boring due to being so accurate

Falco series

Author: Lindsey Davis

Context:

Mentioned as detective novels set in ancient Rome that revel in anachronism

Flashman series

Author: George MacDonald Fraser

Context:

Extensively discussed as having excellent narrative voice capturing Victorian cad, praised for ambiguous treatment of empire

A Tale of Two Cities

Author: Charles Dickens

Context:

Argued to be the single most influential novel on how English-speaking world understands the French Revolution

Ivanhoe

Author: Walter Scott

Context:

Described as influential for establishing idea of medieval England as Saxons vs Normans

Gone with the Wind

Author: Margaret Mitchell

Context:

Mentioned as having seismic influence on how people saw the antebellum South, though influence now dissolved

The Virginian

Author: Owen Wister

Context:

Mentioned as the first Wild West novel establishing template for Hollywood westerns

Don Quixote

Author: Miguel de Cervantes

Context:

Discussed as the first novel in modern West, about tension between past and present

The Underground Railroad

Author: Colson Whitehead

Context:

Mentioned as recent novel weaving fantastical into story of slavery to brilliant effect

The Lord of the Rings

Author: J.R.R. Tolkien

Context:

Mentioned as a more creative response to early medieval history than rigorous historical fiction

Terra Nostra

Author: Carlos Fuentes

Context:

Described as counterfactual novel where Philip II marries Elizabeth Tudor and Don Quixote is a character

The Alteration

Author: Kingsley Amis

Context:

Alternate history where England never went Protestant, about a boy about to be castrated to preserve singing voice

Fatherland

Author: Robert Harris

Context:

Mentioned as fantastic alternate history book, remembered reading on a bus desperate to finish

The Years of Rice and Salt

Author: Kim Stanley Robinson

Context:

Alternate history where Black Death wipes out Europeans and Muslims colonize Europe

The Man in the High Castle

Author: Philip K. Dick

Context:

Mentioned as example of alternate history that integrates critique of the genre

Middlemarch

Author: George Eliot

Context:

Mentioned as example of high-status novel set around time of author's birth that counts as historical

Vanity Fair

Author: William Makepeace Thackeray

Context:

Mentioned as great historical novel set around time of author's birth

The Charterhouse of Parma

Author: Stendhal

Context:

Mentioned as 19th century writer writing about events 20-30 years previous

La Débâcle

Author: Émile Zola

Context:

Mentioned as Zola writing about Franco-Prussian War, events 20-30 years before

Waverley

Author: Walter Scott

Context:

Described as classically the first historical novel, set in Jacobite period, chosen as book to survive apocalypse

The Rotter's Club

Author: Jonathan Coe

Context:

Mentioned as example of people writing historical novels set in 70s and 80s

The Northern Clemency

Author: Philip Hensher

Context:

Mentioned alongside Rotter's Club as historical novel set in recent past

A Journal of the Plague Year

Author: Daniel Defoe

Context:

Mentioned as possibly the very first historical novel, written 70 years after Great Plague of London

The Persian Boy

Author: Mary Renault

Context:

Discussed as middle book in Alexander trilogy, narrated by eunuch Bagoas, with vivid castration description

Fire from Heaven

Author: Mary Renault

Context:

Mentioned as first in Alexander trilogy about Alexander's childhood and youth

Blood Meridian

Author: Cormac McCarthy

Context:

Described as powerful favourite book set in 1850s US-Mexico borderlands about scalp hunters

The Road

Author: Cormac McCarthy

Context:

Mentioned in comparison to Blood Meridian's apocalyptic style

Absalom, Absalom!

Author: William Faulkner

Context:

Mentioned as very difficult book looking back to Civil War and slavery in American South

King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table

Author: Antonia Fraser

Context:

Mentioned by Dominic as the first historical novel he remembers reading as a child