An Unofficial 'The Rest Is History' Reading List
386. The Fall of the Aztecs: The City of Gold (Part 3)
November 09, 2023
Description
Books Referenced
Author: Garci Rodríguez de Montalvo
Context:
Referenced in Bernal Diaz's quote describing the Spanish reaction to seeing Tenochtitlan: 'we thought it was a magical scene from the Book of Mardis' - this refers to the famous Spanish chivalric romance Amadís de Gaula
Author: Bernal Diaz
Context:
Described as 'our best Spanish source' for the conquest - this is Bernal Diaz's memoir of the conquest, referenced multiple times throughout for eyewitness accounts
Author: Juan Miralles
Context:
Explicitly mentioned as 'a book-length study by the Mexican historian Juan Mirales examining the reliability or otherwise of Bernal Diaz'
Author: Camilla Townsend
Context:
Referenced as 'brilliant work on her by Camilla Townsend' regarding Malinche's agency, described as 'a historian we talked about last time' - refers to her scholarly work on the conquest
Author: Hugh Thomas
Context:
Explicitly mentioned: 'If you read Hugh Thomas's book, Conquest' in the context of discussing what sources say about Montezuma's supposed surrender speech
Author: Matthew Restall
Context:
Referenced as 'one on the meeting of Cortez and Montezuma' - described as one of the most intellectually exciting historiographical experiences, came out around 2018-2019
Author: Matthew Restall
Context:
Explicitly mentioned as one of a couple of books by Matthew Restall on this topic, discussing revisionist historiography of the conquest
Author: Patricia Crone
Context:
Mentioned as a comparison for intellectual excitement: 'reading Patricia Croner on The Origins of Islam for the first time' - refers to her revisionist work on early Islamic history